On July 11, 2025, Pennsylvania faced a significant emergency communication crisis when its 911 system experienced widespread intermittent outages. Starting around 2 p.m., emergency call centers in Delaware, York, Montgomery, Philadelphia, and other counties reported dropped calls, incomplete connections, and problems with caller location data. The Pennsylvania Emergency Management Agency (PEMA) quickly alerted the public, emphasizing that the system was experiencing “intermittent” issues rather than a total failure.
Officials urged residents to only use 911 for true emergencies and, if possible, to use alternative non-emergency numbers provided by their local jurisdictions. Despite the problems, many calls still successfully went through, but the outage raised urgent concerns about the reliability of Pennsylvania’s Next Generation 911 (NG911) system.
Why Did Pennsylvania’s 911 System Fail? Common Causes of 911 Outages
The Role of Software Updates in 911 System Failures
The 911 outage came shortly after a software update was pushed to the state’s NG911 infrastructure. NG911 is a modernized, internet-based platform designed to route emergency calls more efficiently. However, initial investigations found no direct evidence that the update caused the failures. Experts say that while software updates can sometimes introduce bugs or incompatibilities, NG911’s design typically prevents a single update from causing widespread outages.
Infrastructure Vulnerabilities: Fiber Cuts and Network Issues
Modern 911 systems rely heavily on telecommunications infrastructure like fiber optic cables and internet connections. In other parts of the country, outages have been traced to physical damage, such as the recent fiber cut in Florida caused by construction work. Such vulnerabilities can disrupt service temporarily and pose a challenge for emergency responders.
Cybersecurity Risks in Emergency Communication
While the Pennsylvania incident has not been linked to a cyberattack, cybersecurity remains a critical concern. NG911 systems are potentially vulnerable to hacking attempts, denial-of-service attacks, and other malicious activities. Experts warn that outdated or poorly secured emergency networks could be exploited, leading to catastrophic consequences for public safety.
What Are the Legal and Regulatory Consequences of a 911 Outage?
Government Accountability and Public Safety Obligations
911 services are legally mandated as essential public safety resources. Failures in these systems can lead to delayed responses during critical emergencies, potentially causing injury or death. As such, government agencies like PEMA have a legal obligation to maintain reliable 911 services. Failure to do so could result in liability claims from individuals harmed by delayed emergency assistance.
Federal and State Oversight of 911 Systems
The Federal Communications Commission (FCC) oversees 911 regulations nationwide, requiring states to ensure operational and accessible emergency systems. State-level agencies are also tasked with compliance and infrastructure maintenance. The Pennsylvania outage could prompt regulatory reviews to ensure adherence to federal mandates and state laws regarding emergency communication standards.
Legal Recourse for Victims of 911 Failures
Victims or families impacted by emergency call failures may seek legal action alleging negligence or failure to properly maintain or upgrade the system. However, pursuing such claims involves navigating government immunity protections and proving direct causation, which can be legally complex.
How Are Officials Responding to the Outage?
PEMA promptly activated emergency protocols by issuing Wireless Emergency Alerts (WEA) and Emergency Alert System (EAS) notifications, informing the public about the issues. Officials advised the public to use backup numbers if 911 calls failed and to avoid making non-essential calls that could further congest the system.
Governor Josh Shapiro emphasized calm and cooperation, assuring residents that full service restoration was a top priority. PEMA teams worked closely with local public safety answering points (PSAPs) and the NG911 service provider to diagnose and resolve the anomaly.
Why Are 911 Outages Becoming More Common Nationwide?
According to the National Emergency Number Association (NENA), nearly 90% of emergency communications centers experienced some level of 911 outage or disruption in the past year. Factors contributing to this trend include:
-
Aging infrastructure struggling to keep up with increasing call volumes
-
Complexities and risks introduced by the transition to NG911 and IP-based systems
-
Physical damage to telecom infrastructure such as fiber cuts or storms
-
Cybersecurity threats targeting critical communication systems
-
Underfunding and lack of modernization in many emergency communication centers
What Can Be Done to Prevent Future 911 Outages?
Investing in Infrastructure Modernization
Robust investments are needed to upgrade 911 infrastructure with redundant networks and backup systems. States must prioritize funding for comprehensive modernization to ensure continuous service during technical glitches or disasters.
Enhancing Cybersecurity Measures
Protecting emergency networks against cyber threats requires dedicated resources for security audits, intrusion detection, and rapid incident response. Emergency communication providers should collaborate with cybersecurity experts to fortify defenses.
Public Education and Proper Use of 911
Educating the public about when and how to use 911 during outages can prevent system overload. Encouraging use of non-emergency lines when appropriate reduces unnecessary call volume and helps prioritize true emergencies.
The Bigger Picture: Why Reliable 911 Service Is Critical
A fully functional 911 system is vital to saving lives, coordinating emergency response, and maintaining public trust. The 2025 Pennsylvania outage serves as a wake-up call to federal and state authorities about the fragility of emergency networks. It underscores the need for coordinated action to build resilient, secure, and responsive systems nationwide.
Conclusion
The Pennsylvania 911 outage illustrates how critical emergency communication infrastructure faces risks from technical glitches, infrastructure vulnerabilities, and potential cybersecurity threats. From a legal standpoint, public agencies have an undeniable responsibility to provide uninterrupted service, or face possible liability.
Preventing future outages requires a multi-pronged approach: investing in modern, redundant systems; enforcing strict regulatory standards; and educating the public on appropriate 911 use. Ultimately, the safety and confidence of the community depend on a reliable, secure, and accessible emergency call system — a goal that must be prioritized by policymakers, emergency managers, and technology providers alike.
FAQ
What Causes 911 Outages Like the One in Pennsylvania?
Outages can stem from software errors, network infrastructure damage, cyberattacks, or equipment failures. Pennsylvania’s outage appears linked to a system anomaly in the NG911 network, though investigations continue.
What Should I Do If I Can’t Reach 911 During an Outage?
Use local non-emergency numbers or administrative backup lines provided by your county or city. Only call 911 for real emergencies to avoid clogging the system.
How Often Do 911 Systems Fail?
While rare, outages are increasing due to aging infrastructure and modernization challenges. According to NENA’s 2025 report, 9 out of 10 emergency centers faced some outage last year.